A medical malpractice claim in Michigan has rules no other injury claim has:
- a two-year deadline instead of three
- a written Notice of Intent served on each provider at least 182 days before suit
- a sworn Affidavit of Merit from a qualified expert, filed with the complaint
- strict rules on who that expert can be
- a cap on pain-and-suffering damages
A case that misses any one of them can be lost before its merits are heard.
In Ann Arbor there is a sixth rule, and it comes first. If the care was given by the University of Michigan, the claim is against the State. It is filed in the Michigan Court of Claims, and a notice of intention, or the claim itself, must be filed with that court within six months. A Notice of Intent mailed to the hospital is not the same thing. For a child’s birth injury, the minority rules that give a child years to sue do not extend the six-month notice.
So the first question in an Ann Arbor case is who gave the care:
- University of Michigan Health, including its hospitals and health centers: the State, in the Court of Claims.
- Trinity Health Ann Arbor and private practices: the ordinary malpractice rules, in the Washtenaw County Trial Court.
- The VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System: the United States, under federal law.
ATLAW has practiced Michigan injury law for 13 years from its office at 3 Parklane Boulevard in Dearborn. The firm has handled more than 10,000 cases and recovered more than $100 million for clients.
- Our Michigan medical malpractice lawyer page covers the law in full.
- Our hospital mistakes, anesthesia error, and birth injury pages cover the main case types.
- Our Ann Arbor page covers every kind of injury claim in the city.
The first conversation is free, in English, Arabic, French, Mandarin, Urdu, or Spanish: (313) 406-7606.
The rules, by the numbers
| Rule | Figure | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Claim against the University of Michigan: notice or claim filed with the Court of Claims | Within 6 months of the event | MCL 600.6431 |
| Deadline to file suit | 2 years from the act or omission | MCL 600.5805(8) |
| Discovery rule | 6 months from when the claim was or should have been discovered, if later; never more than 6 years after the act (exceptions for fraud and reproductive injury) | MCL 600.5838a(2) |
| Notice of Intent before suit | 182 days; the provider must respond in writing within 154 days | MCL 600.2912b |
| Affidavit of Merit | Filed with the complaint | MCL 600.2912d |
| Defendant’s Affidavit of Meritorious Defense | Within 91 days after the answer | MCL 600.2912e |
| Expert qualification | Same specialty; same board certification if the defendant is certified; majority of professional time in that specialty in the year before | MCL 600.2169 |
| 2026 cap on noneconomic damages | $596,400 (standard) / $1,065,000 (catastrophic) | MCL 600.1483 |
| Child injured before age 8 (ordinary claims) | Deadline runs to the 10th birthday | MCL 600.5851(7) |
| VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System | Administrative claim (SF-95) within 2 years; suit after denial or 6 months | 28 USC 2401(b), 2675 |
Economic damages, including medical bills, lost earnings, and the cost of future care, are not capped. The Affidavit of Merit itself is required by MCL 600.2912d; MCL 600.2169 decides who is qualified to sign it.
What malpractice is, and is not
A bad outcome is not malpractice. Malpractice is a bad outcome caused by a provider who failed to do what a reasonably competent provider in the same specialty would have done in the same circumstances (MCL 600.2912a). You must prove:
- the standard of care
- a breach
- that the breach more likely than not caused the injury
- damages
Michigan requires proof that the patient would have had a better outcome. A lost chance of a better outcome is compensable only where that chance was greater than 50 percent (MCL 600.2912a(2)).
A qualified physician’s written review of the records decides, before anything is filed, whether a case exists. Many do not, and we say so.
Care at University of Michigan Health
Who is the State. The University of Michigan, governed by its Board of Regents, is a constitutional state institution. Its hospitals and clinics in Ann Arbor, including University Hospital, C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital, Von Voigtlander Women’s Hospital, and the Frankel Cardiovascular Center, and its health centers across the region, are part of the University. So is University Health Service, where students are treated. A malpractice claim against the University is a claim against the State.
University of Michigan Health also includes hospitals elsewhere in Michigan that joined it through affiliations, such as in Lansing and the Grand Rapids area. Whether each is the University itself or a separate corporation decides whether the State’s rules apply. We confirm the legal entity from the records before any notice is filed.
Immunity does not bar the claim. Michigan’s governmental immunity law does not shield a public hospital from a medical malpractice claim (MCL 691.1407(4)). The claim can be brought. The question is how.
The court. A claim against the University is filed in the Michigan Court of Claims and decided by a judge, not a jury (MCL 600.6419, 600.6443).
The six-month notice. For a personal injury claim against the State, the claimant must file, with the clerk of the Court of Claims, either the claim itself or a written notice of intention to file it, within six months after the event that gave rise to the claim (MCL 600.6431). The notice must be signed and verified under oath and must state the time, place, nature of the claim, and the injuries.
- It is a filing with the court, not a letter to the hospital. The Notice of Intent under MCL 600.2912b is served on the provider. It is a separate requirement, and serving it does not by itself satisfy the Court of Claims notice.
- It is not extended for children. In Taylor v University of Michigan Board of Regents (Mich App, August 18, 2022; unpublished), the Court of Appeals held that the minority tolling statute (MCL 600.5851) does not extend the six-month notice, and ordered a child’s injury claim against the University and C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital dismissed because the notice was filed years late. An unpublished opinion is not binding, but the University will cite it.
- It applies wherever the claim is filed. The Michigan Supreme Court held in Christie v Wayne State University (May 2, 2023) that any claim against the State, wherever it is filed, must comply with the notice requirements of MCL 600.6431.
- It runs from the event. The period runs from the event giving rise to the claim. Where an injury was not apparent at once, whether the period can run from a later date is contested. Do not count on it.
The malpractice rules still apply. The Notice of Intent, the 182-day waiting period, the Affidavit of Merit, the expert rules, and the caps all apply to a claim against the University as well. The Court of Claims notice is in addition to them, not instead of them.
Residents, fellows, and individual physicians. University of Michigan Health is a teaching hospital, and much of the care is given by residents and fellows under attending physicians. The physicians and nurses are University employees. Whether a claim against an individual University physician must also follow the Court of Claims rules, and where it is filed, depends on how the claim is pleaded.
What this means for an Ann Arbor family. If the care was at a University hospital or clinic, call within weeks, not months. The six months can pass while a family is still waiting for records or for a child’s diagnosis to become clear.
Care at Trinity Health Ann Arbor, private practices, and surgery centers
Trinity Health Ann Arbor, formerly St. Joseph Mercy Ann Arbor, is a private, nonprofit hospital in Superior Township. Its employed physicians, nurses, and staff, and the physician groups that practice there, are private defendants. Claims are filed in the Washtenaw County Trial Court, with the ordinary malpractice rules:
- the 182-day Notice of Intent and 154-day response
- the Affidavit of Merit
- the two-year period, with the six-month discovery rule and six-year repose
- the cap
Health-system names and ownership change. The correct legal entity for the Notice of Intent must be identified from current corporate filings and from the name the provider used at the time of care, not from the sign or the letterhead.
Emergency physicians and other contracted groups. Many hospitals staff their emergency departments, anesthesia, and radiology through separate physician groups. The Notice of Intent must name the group as well as the hospital. Where a patient came to the hospital for care and reasonably believed the doctor worked for it, Michigan law can hold the hospital responsible under ostensible agency (Grewe v Mt Clemens General Hospital, 1978).
Medical offices, urgent care, surgery centers, and imaging centers. Primary-care and specialty practices, urgent care clinics, and outpatient surgery, endoscopy, and imaging centers serve Ann Arbor along Washtenaw Avenue, State Street, Plymouth Road, and Jackson Road. The frequent claims are:
- a delayed diagnosis in an office practice
- a missed fracture or infection at urgent care
- a surgical complication at an outpatient center
The employer of each provider who touched the chart must be identified. A University-employed physician and an independent physician in the same building are different defendants, with different rules, courts, and deadlines.
Care at the VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System
Veterans treated at the VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, or one of its outpatient clinics, have a claim against the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act, not a Michigan malpractice claim:
- An administrative claim on Standard Form 95, stating a specific dollar amount, must be filed with the Department of Veterans Affairs within two years after the claim accrues (28 USC 2401(b)).
- There is no Michigan Notice of Intent.
- Suit can be filed in federal court only after the VA denies the claim, or six months pass without a decision, and within six months of a denial (28 USC 2675).
- The case is tried to a federal judge, without a jury.
Serving a Michigan Notice of Intent and waiting 182 days while the federal clock runs can lose the case. A veteran may also qualify for disability compensation under 38 USC 1151 where the injury was caused by VA carelessness, negligence, or error, or by an event that was not reasonably foreseeable.
Federally funded community health centers. Community health centers that receive federal Health Center Program funding, including centers serving Ann Arbor and Ypsilanti, can have their providers deemed federal employees for malpractice purposes. A claim against one follows the same federal path, with the administrative claim filed with the Department of Health and Human Services.
Other Ann Arbor providers
EMS. Emergency ambulance service in Ann Arbor is provided by a private nonprofit ambulance operator, and the Ann Arbor Fire Department responds to medical calls. Claims against EMS personnel, and against the agency that employs them, public or private, are limited by the Emergency Medical Services Act to gross negligence or willful misconduct (MCL 333.20965(1)).
Nursing homes, rehabilitation, and assisted living. Ann Arbor has nursing homes, short-term rehabilitation units, and assisted living and memory care communities. Three Medicare-certified nursing homes have an Ann Arbor address Their claims are sometimes malpractice and sometimes ordinary negligence, and which one it is decides whether the Notice of Intent, the two-year period, and the cap apply. A nurse’s wound-care decision is malpractice. Leaving a resident unsupervised against the care plan is usually negligence. See our nursing home abuse page.
Workplace clinics. A claim against a provider employed by your own employer may be barred by workers’ compensation exclusivity, while an outside clinic or physician can be sued for malpractice. That includes University employees treated by University occupational health. See our Ann Arbor workers’ compensation page.
The Ann Arbor malpractice cases we see
- Emergency department errors: missed stroke, heart attack, sepsis, pulmonary embolism, and bleeds; discharge without a needed test; triage delays.
- Transfers: Ann Arbor’s hospitals receive patients transferred from across the region. A transfer case can involve two hospitals, two sets of physicians, and the transport between them, and the question is which delay or decision caused the harm. If one of the hospitals was a University hospital, the six-month notice applies to that part of the claim.
- Birth injuries: delayed response to fetal distress, mismanaged shoulder dystocia, delayed cesarean, and the cerebral palsy, brachial plexus, and hypoxic injuries that follow. Against a private hospital, a child injured before age eight has until the tenth birthday. Against the University, the six-month notice is not extended. The parents’ own claims do not get the minority extension in either case.
- Pediatric care, including complications of procedures, medication dosing, and missed diagnoses in children.
- Surgical and anesthesia errors, including at outpatient surgery centers: wrong site, retained objects, perforations, and airway and dosing failures causing brain injury.
- Supervision in a teaching hospital: whether an attending physician properly supervised a resident’s decisions.
- Medication errors in hospitals, pharmacies, and nursing homes.
- Cancer misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis in office practices and imaging centers, where the “better outcome” causation standard is argued hardest.
- Falls, pressure injuries, and missed decline in older patients, in the hospital and in nursing and assisted living settings.
- Death from malpractice, brought by the estate with the malpractice rules attached. See our Ann Arbor wrongful death page.
How an Ann Arbor malpractice case proceeds
- Identify who gave the care in the first days: the University, a private hospital or practice, a physician group, the VA, a federally funded clinic, or EMS. If it was the University, the Court of Claims notice is drafted, verified, and filed first. If it was the VA, the SF-95 is prepared.
- The records, including the electronic audit trail, from every provider, requested promptly, under whatever name the provider used at the time of care.
- Expert review by a physician in the defendant’s specialty, in writing, before the Notice of Intent is served.
- The Notice of Intent (MCL 600.2912b), served at least 182 days before suit. A timely notice pauses the two-year period during the notice period (MCL 600.5856(c)). If the provider does not respond within 154 days, suit may be filed then.
- The complaint and Affidavit of Merit (MCL 600.2912d): in the Washtenaw County Trial Court for private providers, or the Court of Claims for the University. The defense then files its own affidavit (MCL 600.2912e).
- Discovery, case evaluation, and facilitation, and, for cases that do not settle, trial. Against a private provider, the trial is to a Washtenaw County jury. Against the University, it is to a judge. Two to four years is typical.
- Resolution, with minors’ and estates’ settlements approved by the court or the Washtenaw County Probate Court, and Medicare, Medicaid, and health plan liens resolved before distribution.
What it costs
Malpractice cases are expensive to bring. The same-specialty expert’s review, affidavit, and testimony alone can run to tens of thousands of dollars. ATLAW handles them on contingency, advances the costs, and recovers them only from a settlement or verdict. Contingent fees in Michigan injury cases are limited to one-third of the net recovery (MCR 8.121). The first conversation is free.
Deadlines for Ann Arbor medical malpractice claims
| What | When | Statute |
|---|---|---|
| Claim against the University of Michigan, including University of Michigan Health | Verified notice or claim filed with the Court of Claims within 6 months; not extended for minors | MCL 600.6431 |
| Suit against a Michigan provider | 2 years from the act or omission | MCL 600.5805(8) |
| Injury not discoverable within 2 years | 6 months from discovery, within 6 years (exceptions) | MCL 600.5838a(2) |
| Notice of Intent | At least 182 days before filing; pauses the period if timely | MCL 600.2912b, 600.5856(c) |
| Affidavit of Merit | With the complaint | MCL 600.2912d |
| Child injured before age 8 (private providers) | 10th birthday | MCL 600.5851(7) |
| Death from malpractice | 2 years, with the estate’s savings provision; no later than 3 years after the 2-year period ends | MCL 600.5805(8), 600.5852(4) |
| VA or deemed health center | SF-95 within 2 years; suit within 6 months of denial | 28 USC 2401(b), 2675 |
| EMS, public or private | Gross negligence standard | MCL 333.20965 |
Why Ann Arbor patients call ATLAW
- 13 years of Michigan injury practice; more than 10,000 cases; more than $100 million recovered.
- The provider, the forum, and the first deadline identified before anything else: the University and the six-month Court of Claims notice, a private hospital or practice, the VA, a federally funded clinic, or EMS.
- Records requested promptly; expert review before the Notice of Intent; costs advanced.
- Honest evaluation: many bad outcomes are not malpractice, and we say so at no charge.
- No attorney fee or case costs unless we recover money for you.
- Consultations can be accommodated in English, Arabic, French, Mandarin, Urdu, and Spanish. We welcome clients to our Dearborn office for a consultation. If you are unable to visit, home or hospital visits can be arranged as needed.











